Richt Should Fire Garner First!

The Bulldog nation is up in arms about the direction of the football program and rightfully so.   It appears the Willie Martinez is on is way out.  Our friends over at have already released their top candidates  (subscription required) for the defensive coordinator position, so it is becoming very clear that Martinez will be released of his duties. 

The Bulldog defense has been in gradual decline since Brian Van Gorder left Athens, and the last two years the bottom has completely fallen out.  Since 2007 , against Tennessee, Florida, Auburn, and Georgia Tech the Dawgs have given up over 31 points per game.  The last three games against Georgia Tech, Tennessee, and Florida, the Dawgs have given up 45, 45, and 41 points per game.  Unacceptable!

However, Martinez should not be the only defensive coach shown the door.  In fact, Rodney Garner should be the first coach let go.  According to sources close to program, Rodney Garner is a “cancer” on this staff, and one of the reasons Kirby Smart is not on this coaching staff today is due to a falling out with Garner. 

Dawgs fans would love for Kirby Smart to head back to Athens and take over this defense in 2010.  Why not?  He’s a Georgia alum and grew up in Bainbridge.  He is arguably the best up and coming young coach in college football.  His wife is former Lady Bulldogs Basketball player Mary Beth Lycett, and she used to work for Claude Felton in the Sports Information Department.  It is believed by some that Mrs Smart wants to get back to Athens.  However, it doesn’t happen with Coach Garner on this staff!  This rift is not only between Smart and Garner.  Sources say it also occured between Garner and Brian Van Gorder.

Coach Garner is about Coach Garner!  When Garner interviewed for a position on the Tennessee staff last season it is believed by insiders that he sought the position.  Garner even went after a position EVEN THOUGH Ed Orgeron  had already been hired as D-line coach.

Bulldog fans give too much credit to Garner for our recruiting success.  Let me point out some flaws the Dawgnation are missing.

1.  Jonathan Dwyer was kicked to the curb and picked by Georgia Tech due to UGA focusing only on Caleb King.  How’s that turned out? 

2.  Georgia lost Eric Berry to Tennessee arguably the most athletic player this state has seen since Herschel Walker.

3.  Garner lost Morgan Burnett to Georgia Tech even though his brother played at Georgia under Jim Donnan and Mark Richt.  Sources claim that Garner assumed Burnett would be a Dawg and let his guard down.   It would be nice to have Burnett at safety instead of Bryan Evans.

4.  Georgia made some disastrous decisions on O-line recruiting.  Through 2007-2009, Georgia has been forced to use inexperienced O-lineman due to bad recruitng decisions and not making the position a recruiting priority.  Just look at the lineman from the state of Georgia that star or have stared other teams.  Chris Scott- 2nd team ALL SEC at Tennessee, Ryan McMahon-ALL ACC Honorable Mention at Florida State, Sergio Render -ALL ACC Va Tech, 2008 ALL ACC Andrew Garner from Georgia Tech.  Garner flat out blew it from 2003-2005 in the area of O-line recruitng.

The University of Georgia has one of the nation’s top football programs and is the flagship university in a state full of high school football talent.  This program sells itself.  It doesn’t need to put with Rodney Garner to be successful.  Which is why the Monday after the Georgia-Georgia Tech game, Garner should be the VERY FIRST COACH called to Richt’s office and immediately shown the door.



8 Responses to “Richt Should Fire Garner First!”

  1. 1 Spence November 6, 2009 at 4:28 pm

    Dumbest post ever. One-sided and doesn’t even begin to address the dozens of recruits that have told us they came here in large part due to Coach Garner.

    • 2 Bulldawgjosh November 6, 2009 at 4:53 pm

      Agree with Spence. This is the dumbest thing I’ve ever voluntarily read. One can only hope this is a parody of some sorts. Otherwise, it is literally one of the worst, most pathetic, and half assed written blog posts I’ve ever seen. Did Paul Finebaum write this and give it to you?

  2. 4 Mick Hubert November 6, 2009 at 5:21 pm

    I am ready for Garner to go too. All he does is string us along in the off seaosn for more money. If you go back and look at the people he recruited from 2005 to 2008, the list aint that impressive. Sure he got some good recruites, but he has missed more than he’s hit in recent years.

    I’m just tired of his drama in the off seaosn too. If we got Travis Jones, Kirby would be here in a flash.

  3. 5 enough November 6, 2009 at 10:00 pm

    enough! Talent lost and talent gotten not capitalized! Gardener, Martinez, Bobo.Whoever! We are Georgia! This is unacceptable! Watch what happens when we get a good DC. Gardner can go! Jeff Owens is a P#$#@! I went to school during the Goof years. I’m getting weird feelings. Excuses,excuses,excuses!

  4. 6 no homer November 7, 2009 at 10:07 am

    You can also add Calvin Johnson to the list.

    The one thing you are missing, like most UGA fans, is that UGA is not neccessarily the best choice for every student athlete.

    GT was right not to offer Caleb King and pursue Jonathan Dwyer. Remember, UGA offered Jonathan Dwyer, but he choose GT over UF and UGA. GT didn’t even offer Caleb King. UGA simply lost the recruiting battle. It had nothing to do with who they wanted and everything to do with where Jonathan Dwyer wanted to go play football.

    According to ESPN UGA is ranked #14 in football tradition and GT is ranked #18. So the schools are close.

    As for Eric Berry, UGA tryed everything they possibly could to get Eric Berry but Eric choose UT over UGA. Kind of like Demarcus Dobbs choose UGA over GT. GT wanted Demarcus Dobbs but Dobbs wanted to go to UGA.

    I think it is arrogance to think that players, from the state of Georgia, somehow should end up at UGA. UGA’s football program is no better than GT. When Scouts rerated the 2004 and 2005 recruiting classes GT had a higher rated class. And of course 2007 GT had a better class. Why? Because GT is a great football program, just like UGA’s, and some players will choose to play there over UGA.

  5. 7 McCallie November 8, 2009 at 12:34 am

    Garner was OFFERED the job at UT and did NOT accept it. Even though, according to you and your toilet bowl sources, he saught the position out. Do us all a favor kensington and start rooting for another team. You won’t not your dumb blogs will be missed.

  1. 1 Monday Morning Links « Leather Helmet Blog Trackback on November 9, 2009 at 8:39 am

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: