Where is Richt without A.J.?

David Hale compared AJ Green to Herschel Walker.  A friend called me Saturday night and made this statement: “Is A.J. Green the Hershel Walker of our generation?” 

I think yes, he is. 

First and foremost, there has not been, nor will there ever be, another player that is greater than Herschel Walker.  There is whole idea in sports that there is going to be the “next” something.  Is: Sidney Crosby the next Wayne Gretsky, Kobe the next Michael Jordan.  Lebron James the next Magic Johnson, Tom Brady the next Joe Montana, etc…? 

There is never going to be another Michael Jordan.  There is never going to be another Hershel Walker.  But for the generation who was not even born when Herschel was stalking the goal lines, is A.J. this generation’s version of Hershel Walker?  We know about the exploits and the on the field talent and what they mean for their teams.  Whenever both of them get on the field, they are the best player.  They can’t be stopped.  They are/were men among boys.   Here is another comparision between the two: what about their contributions to their head coaches’ careers? 

and…

Coach Dooley had 6 SEC titles, 3 of which came when Herschel was lined up in the I. There are many games in the 1980 season we don’t win if it were not for him.  Period.  Also, Coach Dooley wouldn’t be enshrined in bronze on Lumpkin Street if it were not for Herschel Walker.  That is not a controversial statement I don’t think, it is a fact.  Coach Dooley needed #34 to save his job.  If we were in today’s world, Coach Dooley would not have made it out of the 1970s.  1976 was the lone SEC Title in that decade.  We went 5-6 in 1977 and 6-5 in 1979.  We go on to have unlimited success in the early 1980s, followed by years of marginal success in the mid to late 1980s. 

I think AJ is as equally important to Mark Richt’s tenure here at UGA.  Our fan base is spoiled and Richt is a victim of his own success.  At this juncture in his career, Mark Richt is more successful than any other coach in UGA history.   Paul Finebuam wrote this summer that if Coach Richt can’t beat Tech this year, he will be on the hot seat.  I find that line of thinking absurd. 

But unfortunately, we live in an era where Tommy Tuberville gets fired four seasons after going undefeated.  Blogs, muckraking journalist and “The World Wide Leader”, combined with the exorbitant salaries coaches receive, make fans and administrators’ patience very short.  Coaches aren’t given enough time to recruit a young man and see him graduate.  We are a “win now” society.  That is another post for another day.  But I would venture to say that if it were not for A.J. Green, we probably would have lost to Kentucky and Auburn last year.  In those games, he not only made game winning catches, but the catches were so impressive I am not sure that any one of our receivers could have made them.  A.J. turned a 7-5 year to a 10-3 year.  This season, I honestly believe that without A.J. Green, the Bulldogs would be 0-4.  With all fans complaining of a 10-3 campaign, could you imagine if we started 0-4?  “For Sale” billboards would be popping up, and no amount of SEC Titles, Sugar Bowl appearences, adopted children, or good Christian messages would save Mark Richt’s job.  Is that right?  No.  Is it the truth?  Yes. 

Go Dawgs!

Corbindawg

4 Responses to “Where is Richt without A.J.?”


  1. 1 Puffdawg September 29, 2009 at 5:43 pm

    This is quite possibly the dumbest article I’ve ever read. And I usually enjoy your stuff. The basis of the whole article is irrelevant. Coach Richt DOES have AJ, and he does because he is one hell of a recruiter. Coach Dooley DID have Herschel. This post smacks of an AJC hack reaching for hits. I’m tired of all of our fans bitching about “if this and if that.”. We are 3 and 1. Mark Richt is a great coach. AJ is a great player. The Dawgs have a good and possibly great team. Let’s enjoy the season without second guessing everything that happens.

  2. 2 Gators Wear Jean Shorts September 29, 2009 at 6:04 pm

    I don’t think it’s the dumbest thing I’ve ever read. He’s not bashing CMR or Willie like others out there. I happen to agree that AJ has been the difference in several wins this year, and that in the world we live in today, he would probably be in the hot seat were it not for AJ.

    True, CMR did a great job getting AJ, but CRG also played a pretty big role in landing him.

    I had to read it again to make sure I wasn’t missing anything, and it looks fairly objective from here.

    (BTW, good blog guys.)

  3. 3 BuyPropertyUcheeDawg! September 29, 2009 at 7:42 pm

    Hey Puff Girl

    This doesn’t sound like second guessing to me. It sounds like a very objective analysis of the fan base and the current environment of football, especially in the SEC.

    All he is doing is pointing out that all it takes is one or two special players to make a team special (see Knowshon 2007, Cadillac 2004, and another that I won’t mention from last year.)

    Puff Girl must be having a bad hair day

  4. 4 Puffdawg September 30, 2009 at 4:11 pm

    “Also, Coach Dooley wouldn’t be enshrined in bronze on Lumpkin Street if it were not for Herschel Walker. That is not a controversial statement I don’t think, it is a fact.”

    That is purely speculative. Definitely not factual. Who says we don’t sign Bo Jackson if Herschel doesn’t come to Athens. Obviously a reach, but if you can speculate, I can too. I’d love for you to say that to Vince Dooley if and when you ever met him. What a slap in the face to one of the UGA greats. “Hey Coach Dooley, your coaching career sucks except for the Herschel years.” Nice.

    “But I would venture to say that if it were not for A.J. Green, we probably would have lost to Kentucky and Auburn last year. In those games, he not only made game winning catches, but the catches were so impressive I am not sure that any one of our receivers could have made them. A.J. turned a 7-5 year to a 10-3 year. This season, I honestly believe that without A.J. Green, the Bulldogs would be 0-4.”

    Again, purely speculative and probably moreso than the previous quote. Definitely not factual.

    “True, CMR did a great job getting AJ, but CRG also played a pretty big role in landing him.”

    Who employs Rodney Gardner?

    I’m not looking to bash the authors of this website because I usually enjoy what they write. But this hit a particular nerve. We’re NOT 0-4, so what is the point of speculating on what would happen if we were? Nobody knows whether Coach Mark Richt is on the hotseat but Damon Evans. Not you. Not me. Not Herschel Walker or AJ Green. But the reason there is so much speculation (absurd, mind you) is because stuff like this is put out there. I think the point of the article was to commend AJ for his great play, but it definitely does not come across that way. Just saying…


Leave a reply to Puffdawg Cancel reply